This is in direct response to Liz Conti’s incensed letter demanding the creation of a brand new investigatory body that will absolutely never turn Orwellian nor further clog up the arteries of our already-hideously-sclerotic local government.
Even setting aside the rank conspiracism — really, is EVERY council member who disagrees with you NECESSARILY on the take, or are you just happy to see me — Liz is barking up the wrong tree.
Norwalk’s problem, in stark microcosm of America’s broader electoral problem, is the two-party system.
Liz’s proposal for some unspecified number of Democrat-, Independent- (which ones??), and Republican-appointed “citizens” (funny how they’re appointed instead of elected) would just further entrench those two parties’ dominance over our system. Why do we keep writing and proposing laws that just *assume* the Democrats and Republicans will continue to run things forever? Why do we keep writing and proposing laws that assume there’s some undifferentiated blob of “Independents” who can be adequately represented by whatever table scraps the two major parties allow them?
Our national two-party system was a predictable result of what political science calls “Duverger’s Law”: The observation that, absent disrupting conditions, the first-past-the-post or “plurality” voting system we use will always tend to create two-party systems. It was certainly not desired nor foreordained by our Founders — Duverger made his observation decades after our nation’s birth, so they simply couldn’t have known, and if they had, they’d likely have opted for something else.
The consolidation of the two-party system into two closed coalitions began after the Civil War and was completed by the 1920s, when the Democrats and Republicans managed to box out the Progressive insurgency by stealing portions of its platform — Republicans got conservatism, and Democrats economic populism and social liberalism. This consolidation meant that at the state and local levels, most elections would become uncompetitive (only as much as 1/5 of elections are in any doubt in any given cycle) and most places would be run for long periods of time by a consolidated one-party machine.
This sort of weight is simply not going to be defeated by fantasies like Liz’s Citizens’ Council or “minority party representation”. It’s going to get defeated by forcing the two parties to allow proportional representation. PR eliminates the evils of gerrymandering, forces parties to actually FIGHT for their seats instead of handing them to the minority as charity, and most crucially, allows for more than two parties to be viable.
Liz’s proposal is reactionary, vindictive and guaranteed to fail at its stated objectives. Even if “successful”, it would create a constant state of paranoia and investigation by whichever party the Independents woke up disliking that day. It is not conservative — it is not careful, measured, nor prudent. After all, she is proposing this mere DAYS after a council decision not going her way. (For the record, I *also* oppose the roundabout project!)
This is not the way.
The way is to dislodge this hateful two-party duopoly so that our local elections can be competitive again. I *want* voices like Liz’s to be heard, through the mechanism of her party duly winning ~40-45% of Norwalk’s seats in direct proportion to their 40-45% of votes. The real question is, why is Liz happy with “minority party representation,” handing her maybe an extra 2 seats in addition to the 1 out of 15 that they occasionally win, instead of a PR system that would give her party 6-7 seats in most elections?
David Muccigrosso
Editor’s note: This piece is an opinion article. The views expressed are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the perspectives of the publication or its staff.










Leave a Reply
You must Register or Login to post a comment.