Quantcast

Letter To the Editor: What if Norwalk cut just one department?

As Ashley recently reported, BET has asked all city departments to prepare for up to 10% budget cuts from their initial proposals, in order to help pay for the massive education budget overruns.

I have an alternative.

Why don’t we just cut ONE department?

Specifically P&Z. A 90% cut should, most things being equal, cover 9 extra departments!

What would we do with their portfolio? Well, we’d convert all permitting to “by-right”, meaning that every project would be assumed to be OK, and the staff could simply do a quick compliance check that might take them at most a day or so.

No more tax rebates for developers. No more insane, drawn-out processes. If you have the money and the property, you can build anything that’s currently legal under the zoning code. Period.

The flip side is that without tax rebates, this would lead to a DRAMATIC expansion of the Grand List. By cutting this one department to the bone, we would not only save on 90% of their budget; we’d probably make up the entire education shortfall and THEN some! It would be an embarrassment of riches!

The best thing here is, this would all be compliant with the zoning code that our very own NIMBYs had a STRONG hand in shaping — who can forget the way they nobly protected us from the dastardly plot to DOUBLE our population a few years ago?

We can all rest assured that this is the most NIMBY-compliant plan POSSIBLE. Surely, they will have ZERO objections to balancing our budget by cutting wasteful spending and bureaucratic nightmares that are hurting our small business owners and choking out small-time builders!

This plan is a win-win all around. Norwalkers would throw parades for the mayor who rescued us from this budget crisis, and build statues (among a LOT of other things!) memorializing her heroic actions.

Comments

7 responses to “Letter To the Editor: What if Norwalk cut just one department?”

  1. Peter Marino

    “Norwalkers would throw parades… build statues…” the only parade happening after this plan is the parade of lawyers marching into City Hall with lawsuits because someone does something like building a stripclub between a church and a preschool. This is pure municipal chaos.. LMAOOoo

    1. David Muccigrosso

      Peter, that’s absurd.

      That kind of use is already illegal under the current zoning code, which my proposal specifically says would be preserved. The ONLY difference is that, IN a location where a strip club would ALREADY be permitted today, MY proposal would take the builder days or weeks to get approval, instead of years.

  2. Adam Blank

    I agree wholeheartedly with the notion of simplifying the permitting process to facilitate development. Of course, most of P&Z staff time is spent reviewing over-the-counter permits, enforcing zoning violations and planning for the City’s future. What the author is suggesting here is really to eliminate special permit process and move that to as-of-right, over-the-counter approval. That would save some time, maybe allow for the elimination of 1 or 2 staff. (Of course, state law prohibits this for certain applications). The author’s proposal wouldn’t actually save the City much money.

    In my view, as someone who regularly works with developers to obtain approvals, simplifying the process on large projects would be welcome, however, it is not often a barrier to development. Compliance is really an issue for the smaller multifamily (think less than 20 units) and smaller commercial uses like the mom-and-pop stand-alone retail store or small industrial property. I would like to see the City come up with a 10 or so architectural plans for common building types (duplex, 3 unit townhouse, etc.) that are “pre-approved” and if a builder uses one of those plans they come in and get not just zoning approval but building permit and fire sign-off same day. Maybe the CIty hires an architect on staff to help smaller builders get plans into compliance and expedite the process.

    1. David Muccigrosso

      FWIW Adam, part of the title was accidentally omitted — this was supposed to be pitched in the “modest proposal” archetype.

      I’m aware that the ACTUAL path towards fixing these budget problems wouldn’t be so simplistic. We probably agree on most of the finer details — I’d LOVE for pre-approved plans that allow us to build more “Washington-Street-style” buildings that expand the historically protected pattern further into SoNo.

      But unfortunately we have NIMBYs left and right complaining about their property taxes as if they haven’t benefited from 2-4x increases in their home values BECAUSE of their relentless NIMBYism, and they sit there acting as if the problem is all inefficient government bureaucracy, even though THEY are the ones who IMPOSED what bureaucracy DOES impact our fiscal picture.

  3. Bryan Meek

    Economic and Community development could be eliminated tomorrow and no one would notice except we’d have $7 million extra. The city functioned just fine before this and in fact had more corporations. We have a highly functioning local chamber of commerce and scores of volunteer organizations that cost us nothing for the same benefits. TMP needs to move back to DPW where grownups can decide to patch crumbling infrastructure before building sidewalks no one wants or uses. The third area is NPS needs to stop providing community medical services. We have a health department already. Sadly I’m hearing things are already moving in the opposite direction with more staff hires for functions we never had.

    1. David Muccigrosso

      Surprisingly, Brian, I actually agree with you on all counts!

      RE the first, the various redevelopment offices have really not provided much bang-for-the-buck, for the simple fact that you can’t *redevelop* much of anything if the permitting process is too onerous in the first place. To borrow the garden-hose metaphor, you can turn the spigot all the way to max flow, but if some kid has their thumb over the other end or has kinked the hose, you won’t get much coming out the other end.

      RE the second, we should prioritize TMP’s infrastructure duties in the highest net-revenue-per-square areas. It’s insane that several years after Grit Ninja opened, we still have that tragedy-waiting-to-happen without a proper crosswalk; likewise, the sidewalks all along West Main where our most valuable businesses are, are a MESS right now. We shouldn’t be dumping millions into disruptive sidewalks-to-nowhere that unnecessarily anger NIMBY suburbanites, while we ignore our city’s prime moneymakers like Washington Prime.

      RE the third, services creep is real and an absurd driver of unnecessary costs. Why do our schools have an entirely separate admin for providing community medical services when we already have one?!? It’s one thing to add functionality, but just duplicating admins is wasting money that could actually be HELPING people.

      —–
      Setting aside the “modest proposal” satirical format I chose for the top-level letter, I think that the core problem with development is actually that Wall Street is perfectly happy to finance big boondoggle apartment towers that sit empty with absurd prices, but never just the simple projects like duplex conversions or modest <20-unit projects like Adam Blank supports. The primary reason is that it's difficult to properly underwrite such irregular projects without specialized knowledge in every locality.

      Thus, my ACTUAL big idea for redeploying P&Z is to turn it into an underwriting bureau. They already know the ins and outs of the zoning code and how to value local properties. Why are we having them block small-time developers and contractors from doing gentle-density projects, instead of having them HELP those projects get underwritten and fast-tracked through zoning? Seems like a no-brainer to me.

  4. Spectacular plan I would love a lot of the rebate BS for low-income housing to be completely removed especially since it’s not a reality. These guys are getting huge tax deductions for putting up $3,600 a month studios it’s insanity we have units in Norwalk that are more expensive Central Park South that are supposed to be have a fair amount of low income housing and when you actually stop by one of these places it’s a bunch of 20 and 30 somethings that are obviously being helped out by their parents or a bunch of people with questionable paperwork over the border where’s that funding coming from and the homeless shelter still full so obviously the taxpayers are not getting the low income housing we’re paying for

Leave a Reply

Secret Link