A fellow Norwalker recently encouraged me to keep up my writing, so it felt like a sign from the universe to go ahead and finish this letter draft.
No shade to Ashley, but a thought occurred to me recently when seeing her weekly headline rounding up city meetings for public comment: Why do we need to “Speak Up” about EVERYTHING? Neighbors, citizens, fellow Norwalkers, I humbly submit that we do not NEED to do so.
Is traffic REALLY a life-altering concern befitting 3 or less minutes’ of the taxpayers’ time, or is it something you can get by with complaining to your best friend on a bar stool over beers?
Are weed dispensaries truly such hateful nuisances that we can ONLY tolerate a handful of them, or are we already mostly making do with the externalities of the dozens of black-market shops already operating, and could stand to benefit from legalizing them?
Is spreading the tax burden among a slightly larger population with each new apartment tower truly such an ugly thing, or does the latest tower on West Ave not really impact anyone living in a cul-de-sac in Cranbury or the Silvermine all that much?
Is all the goose and dog crap that permeates my running path at Veterans’ Park REALLY the worst thing in the world, or can I simply tolerate those evil winged beasts as the respective costs of having both environmental laws and a dense, walkable city full of neighbors who want to indulge their right to own a pet and are sometimes careless in the process?
America was built on a proud tradition of using our 1st Amendment rights to protest unjust government. But our modern politics of “accountability” give out far too many soapboxes, and in the process give us all excuses to be the worst cranks we can be from those soapboxes. Too often, our culture of accountability politics encourages us to “Speak Up”, to stand up for our “rights” as if we’re some noble Jimmy Stewart character speaking truth to power, when the reality is that we’re just experiencing another of life’s ENDLESS daily inconveniences and indignities.
This culture is toxic. Accountability politics tells us that we are good and noble for telling ourselves that we are surrounded by wolves, and should therefore cry “wolf” whenever we feel like it. Wolves trying to change our neighborhood character, wolves trying to profit off development, wolves increasing our traffic or using up our fresh water. But like in the story, there usually IS no wolf.
And the lesson of that story wasn’t just that people wouldn’t trust the boy when he needed them; it was also that he was wasting everyone else’s time! Likewise, “accountability” politics stretches out the very same timelines that its loudest voices decry. The Empire State Building was famously built in just over a year; the Walk Bridge will barely make it under 8 years. Every demand for accountability adds a new requirement to the project. Every lawsuit adds another year, or 2, or 5, or 20 — it took THIRTEEN from the first failures of the Walk Bridge to the first shovel going into the ground. Every one of those years only gave more ammo to detractors who complained about late timelines — it’s almost like that’s what they WANTED.
Maybe if we had fewer meetings and hearings, ordinary citizens could find it easier to attend and have their reasonable concerns heard.
Maybe if the same handful of squeaky wheels had a smaller soapbox, we’d free up time for our politicians to seek out and hear more from those ordinary citizens who have jobs and lives to attend to.
Maybe if we fixed our local elections so that more people could vote and more parties could win seats (through proportional representation), people would feel like the system was actually responding to them.
Maybe if we had more bars, convenience stores, day cares, and other local businesses zoned to be allowed throughout our neighborhoods and on our closest street corners, we would have more bar stools to complain from, and more friends to complain to over beers. And less traffic to complain about, less drunk driving, less pollution from all those extra car trips.
Knicks in five.
David Muccigrosso
Editor’s note: This piece is an opinion article. The views expressed are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the perspectives of the publication or its staff.










Leave a Reply
You must Register or Login to post a comment.