Quantcast
Advertisement

Shellfish bed closures stir concerns about Norwalk sewage treatment plant

NORWALK, Conn. – An unusual number of shellfish bed closures this winter brought an unusual number of people to Monday’s Water Pollution Control Authority meeting.

“To have closures in the dead of winter, especially the number we were having, it was just unusual. Also, with all the development that’s going in, the apartments they’re putting in, we’re just a little concerned that the sewer plant can handle everything. It’s the storm water, the run off and all of that,” Tim Cramer said, explaining why he had come with three compatriots, including Norm Bloom of Norm Bloom and Sons Oysters, to the meeting.

The problems trace to sewer work done in Rowayton and on Moody’s Lane, Department of Public Works Supervising Environmental Engineer Ralph Kolb said, expressing confidence that the water quality is better now.

“Down by Farm Creek we did have a couple of issues with Pine Point sewer,” Kolb said. “In the process of us rehabbing it we did have a couple of spills. At that time as well the counts did shoot up. Once we got the line repaired the counts went down.”

Those are virus counts; virus counts are used in winter and bacteria counts are used in summer, he said.

There was also a rain storm that caused a closure, he said.

Bypass pumps will be installed soon and then 250 feet of PVC pipe will replace the current sewer line, he said.

“In that vicinity, we should be good with sanitary sewer,” Kolb said.

As far as Moody’s Lane goes, Dick Harris of Harbor Watch did some water sampling and found high bacteria counts, Kolb said. City workers subsequently found a sewage line on Harbor Avenue, from a home to the street, that had failed. A few days later a sinkhole developed on the street from another failed line, he said.

The Health Department got involved because the problems were on private property and repairs are being made, Kolb said. Harbor Watch will continue testing, he said.

“Great response from the city. Nothing but great. We’re here for support, we want to help,” Bloom said.

WPCA Chairman Darren Oustafine said Monday night’s turnout was the most people he had seen at a WPCA meeting, with the exception of the recent public hearing on the sewage treatment plant’s permit renewal.

“I saw people who I never saw before and it made no sense for them to come to the hearing because we’re going to operate a wastewater treatment plant,” Oustafine said. “The city cannot do without a wastewater treatment plant. It was going to be renewed and they talked about everything from odors to mismanagement and all kinds of aspersions that were unfounded, in my opinion. I really appreciate someone showing up at a regular old normal meeting to express their opinion. … Please come back any old time.”

“The city has been responding greatly on finding problems and fixing them,” Bloom said after the meeting. “We just want to show support, make sure it keeps going and make sure thing are going because we do experience more closures and a lot of that is due to weather, getting more rain, whatever. There’s been more and more testing.”

With more apartments being built, “we get worried about making sure our sewer plant can handle it,” Bloom said. “We’ll start paying attention, start watching. This is very important to us.”

Comments

10 responses to “Shellfish bed closures stir concerns about Norwalk sewage treatment plant”

  1. Mike Mushak

    Here we go again. Almost exactly one year ago, on May 20th, 2014, Nancy on Norwalk published an article about the so-called “award winning” treatment plant that ironically was and still is under state decree from DEEP to clean up its operations and reduce raw sewage spills into our precious harbor (28 times in 2010 alone.)

    I commented on it at that time along with many others. Today’s comment from me is a paraphrase of that comment one year ago, because the WPCA seems still unwilling to be forthcoming with all of the facts to the public related to last year’s permit hearing, based on comments made in today’s article.

    All the public wanted then, and wants now, is a truthful and respectful response from officials including the WPCA, including a clear plan for remedies. Our shellfish and recreational boating industries are multi-million dollar industries that employ hundreds of local folks and generate enormous economic benefits for Norwalk, and they deserve answers and professionalism from officials, not reprimands and criticism for simply asking questions.

    Here is a link to an article that describes how Norwalk “screwed up”.

    http://www.ctpost.com/local/article/Aging-and-failing-wastewater-plants-sending-1308610.php#page-2
    .
    This is from the link:
    .
    “Norwalk’s system discharged raw sewage 28 times in 2010, mostly in periods of heavy rain. A ruptured main pipe and equipment failure contributed to three of the incidents.
    When these types of failures in any system cause sewage discharges, the DEP looks to consent decrees.
    “In these cases we tell towns, `OK, guys, you screwed up. Tell us how you plan to fix it, and then fix it,”’ said Greci. “We prefer to get consent decrees, where we say, `We’ve got enough to whap you upside the head. Take care of this.’ We establish realistic timelines and accomplishable goals in our consent orders. We know what the realities are.”
    .
    Also, the contractor running the plant in a 20 year, $13 million contract paid for by taxpayers was investigated by federal EPA criminal investigators for contract violations including a raid on their offices at the treatment plant as seen here:http://www.waterindustry.org/New%20Projects/OMI-3.htm.

    It would be in the best interest of tax-paying Norwalk residents and businesses to not have to fear criticism from any official including the WPCA for simply asking questions about a huge publicly-owned facility that taxpayers have invested hundreds of millions of dollars in over the years, a facility that protects public health and safety and local industries along with the delicate marine environment, especially when that “award-winnning” facility has a checkered past to the point Norwalk was told by the state in no uncertain terms that the plant operators “screwed up” enough to warrant legal action by the state and a federal investigation.

    This arrogance towards the public on such an important issue of public health and safety is not helpful, and only makes the WPCA look like they are hiding something or not in touch with reality.

  2. EveT

    Glad someone brought up the concern about more apartments being built. Our infrastructure can only support so many people. Population growth might increase our tax base but mess our quality of life.
    Also, doesn’t Norwalk’s sewage treatment plant process Darien’s sewage? Maybe it’s time for Darien’s taxpayers to shell out the money to build their own plant that would discharge into their own shore area.

    1. @EveT
      I believe you are correct. Norwalk’s sewage treatment plant also processes Darien’s sewage, I am told.

  3. Terra Firma

    “I saw people who I never saw before and it made no sense for them to come to the hearing because we’re going to operate a wastewater treatment plant,” Oustafine said. “The city cannot do without a wastewater treatment plant. It was going to be renewed and they talked about everything from odors to mismanagement and all kinds of aspersions that were unfounded, in my opinion. I really appreciate someone showing up at a regular old normal meeting to express their opinion. … Please come back any old time.”

    It seems the powers that be are still sulking that the public got a chance to exercise their rights without being bullied into silence.

    Did the WPCA board investigate those “aspersions”? Or did they just assume that the public had nothing better to do that night than go sit in an industrial building and make up stories?

    Did you ever ask yourselves whether complaints from the public were a signal that you missed stuff? Do you think maybe, just maybe, there might be something you could be doing better?

    And what happened with the Flowserv pump failure litigation?

    1. @ Terra Firma
      The litigation over the failed sewage treatment plant lift pumps is still ongoing. Last night the WPCA held a brief executive session on the topic, then authorized its legal firm to subcontract work to another legal firm. I do not at this moment have the cost for that.

  4. DianeLauricella

    Time again for placing facts on the table.
    Thank you NON, for publishing Chairman Oustafine’s comments, as I was not there to bear witness. I plan to invite him to meet with me so that his misconceptions about the permit renewal process, many advocated by staff present and past, can be clarified.

    “I saw people who I never saw before and it made no sense for them to come to the hearing because we’re going to operate a wastewater treatment plant,” Oustafine said. “The city cannot do without a wastewater treatment plant. It was going to be renewed and they talked about everything from odors to mismanagement and all kinds of aspersions that were unfounded, in my opinion”.

    Wow. In addition to the insightful discussion by previous commenters, may I help clarify that when the CTDEEP plans to renew a sewage treatment plant permit, they must, under CT State law, publish the tentative decision in a local newspaper. Anyone from the public may request a hearing if they gather requisite names on a special petition and feel that their concerns have not been resolved, as was the case with the public hearing request in the early Fall of 2014. This is an important right that citizens have in order to allow further discussion of a permit if desired or warranted. In this case, those of us (30+) who petitioned for a public hearing did not do so in order to stop the functioning of the plant, but to request that the CTDEEP look into several practices that we were rightly concerned about, including the real and known economic development-killing odors emanating from the sludge storage facility, and impose special conditions that would make the plant run better.

    Kind of a case of the Emperor’s New Clothes? Again, the inconvenient truth is that the State and City held the hearing right after a major holiday without caring about public convenience, in a remote location, with Ms. Burns taking to online comment browbeating in the hours before the hearing trying to convince the public they had nothing to be concerned about. Amazing. In addition, in the months after the public hearing some of us were subject to defamatory remarks as the staff proceeded to quietly plan for a $200,000+ engineering study to replace the odor-causing facility that many were concerned about in the first place!

    To top off the irony, there was an announcement yesterday that the city will now have an APP (a great idea frankly), for public to file concerns and complaints, and Ms. Burns admits that there are odor problems even in the present day!

  5. Jason

    Sounds like a great time to be without a DPW director.

  6. Terra Firma

    Sorry Nancy. Didn’t mean for YOU to answer that. Thought someone from WCPA might, given that they’ve been known to spend time here.

    No agenda for last night’s meeting on the city calendar, here:

    http://www.norwalkct.org/Calendar.aspx?EID=6696&day=18&month=5&year=2015&calType=0

    Found it here:
    http://norwalkct.org/Archive/162

    You are right. It’s under executive session.

  7. Oldtimer

    Doesn’t Mr Oustifine work for the town of Darien and live in Norwalk ?
    Darren J. Oustafine, P.E., Assistant Director of Public Works doustafine@darienct.gov
    Is there a conflict of interest ?

  8. Oldtimer

    Closing the shellfish beds is done by the State Dept. of Agriculture, bureau of aquaculture. In the interest of protecting public health, they tend to err on the side of caution, and that is a good thing. They take a long time re-opening closed beds, claiming they do not have the resources to do the testing as often as they, and the shellfishermen, might prefer. Offers have been made to help, but they are reluctant to trust anybody else to take samples or do lab work properly, again, in an abundance of caution. The large companies have beds outside of the harbor, but the smaller companies do not, and are out of business for times when the harbor are closed. Stopping the spills would be a big help.

Leave a Reply

Secret Link